Water pipe renewals
Town staff wrote in November 2025 that water reserve savings are too low, so some needed water pipe renewals have been put off.
- Amount
- $48M–$88M (estimate)
- Got
- $0
- Where it stands
- To future years. Staff, Nov 2025: water reserve savings are too low, so required renewals were deferred.
What it is
The Town runs its own water system, with about 108 km of water mains. Asbestos-cement pipe is an older type of pipe made of cement mixed with asbestos fibres. How much the Town has depends on the source: 25 km in service in the Town's public mapping data, 26 km reported to Statistics Canada in 2022, 27 km in the 2026–2030 Financial Plan, and 28.5 km in an October 2025 staff report. Staff say some of it has less than 15 years of life left. The Town's mapping also lists about 4.9 km of asbestos-cement sewer pipe, 0.3 km of storm pipe, and about 2.2 km of old water pipe marked "abandoned," meaning left in the ground.
In November 2025, staff wrote that yearly savings put into the Water Infrastructure Reserve are too low for the replacement work needed. They said required water renewals "have been deferred to future years."
Staff wrote this in a planning sheet about a request from the Qualicum Beach Memorial Golf Club to help pay for its irrigation system. Staff advised against lending water reserve money for that. The records do not list which water projects were put off.
What it could cost: $48 million to $88 million. The low end is the Town's own estimate from October 2025: $48 million for 28.5 km of water pipe at $1,600 to $2,650 per metre, in 2025 dollars. It fits what the Town has actually paid: about $1,590 a metre on Hemlock Street and Illiqua Road in 2025, and about $1,440 a metre on Seacrest Place in 2026. The high end is our own estimate. It adds the sewer pipe ($10.8 million), the storm pipe ($0.9 million) and removal of abandoned pipe (up to $3.6 million), all at the Town's rates, then 4% yearly construction inflation with the work spread over 2026 to 2040. The Town's plan budgets $8.3 million for this work over five years. The renewals staff said were deferred have no dollar figure in the records.
What the Town plans to spend
| Project | Year | Budget |
|---|---|---|
| Seacrest Place (310 m) | 2026 | $900,000 |
| Berwick Road and Crescent Road East | 2027–28 | $3,013,000 |
| Eaglecrest Drive | 2028 | $1,113,000 |
| Hall Road north of Highway 19A | 2029 | $800,000 |
| Canyon Crescent | 2029 | $865,000 |
| Belyea and Canyon Crescent, Hoylake to Garrett Road | 2030 | $1,600,000 |
| Total | $8,291,000 |
Source: 2026–2030 Financial Plan, p. 122. With pumps and a $100,000 yearly contingency, planned water renewal totals $8,891,000 over the five years. The Town values its whole water system (wells, reservoirs, pumps and mains) at about $109 million to replace, in 2019 dollars (p. 121). In June 2026 the Eaglecrest Drive water main was combined with the storm main into a $2,863,000 project, now waiting on a federal grant.
Is the water safe to drink?
Breathing in asbestos dust causes cancer. That is proven. The clearest danger from these pipes is to work crews who cut or dig up old, dry pipe, which is why WorkSafeBC has rules for that work. 2,7
Drinking water that runs through asbestos-cement pipe is different. Health Canada, the World Health Organization, the US Environmental Protection Agency and Australia have all reviewed the studies. None found consistent evidence that swallowing asbestos causes cancer. 1,2,4,5 The warning signs, mostly for stomach cancer, come from weak studies, or from Norwegian lighthouse keepers whose rainwater held thousands of times more fibres than normal pipe water. 6 The US limit of 7 million fibres per litre is based on non-cancerous growths in the intestines of rats. 3 Health Canada and the World Health Organization say breathing in fibres from shower water is not expected to be a concern. 1,2
But no proof of harm is not the same as no risk. In January 2026, Health Canada's draft guidance said most asbestos-cement pipe in Canada is "at or near the end of their useful life span." 1 It says pipe that is failing or wearing out badly should be replaced with asbestos-free pipe, and that water should be kept from eating away at it. Fibre levels can jump after breaks, repairs and high-flow flushing, so it advises testing at hydrants and after those events. It says tap samples "may not be an appropriate indicator" of how worn the pipe is. 1,8
Qualicum Beach's asbestos-cement pipe was mostly laid in the 1960s and 1970s. In October 2025, staff wrote that tests on samples of the pipe "confirmed that the AC pipes will need to be replaced in the next 10-20 years." 9 Most of the Town's water comes from the River wells, and their water is soft: hardness of about 44 to 52 mg/L at four of the five wells in 2025. 10 Soft water wears cement pipe faster. The wells tested slightly acidic in 2023 and about neutral in 2024 and 2025. 11 The Town doesn't report alkalinity, which is needed to judge how corrosive the water is to the pipe.
The only test of the Town's water for asbestos that we found was in 2023. Of 8 samples from four of the Town's sampling sites, 7 found no fibres and one found a single fibre. 12 The memo doesn't say where the sites were, when the samples were taken, or which fibre sizes were counted. We found no tests at hydrants or after work on mains.
Residents and staff have raised strong views. At the September 9, 2026 Council meeting, staff told Council that swallowing asbestos is not harmful and that there is no risk. 13 Health Canada's wording is more careful: it says there is no consistent, convincing evidence of harm. 1 A resident's video commentary posted on September 29 raises concerns about cancer from drinking or showering in water with asbestos fibres. 14 We haven't yet seen studies that show those risks, but we're still looking. If you know of one, please tell us. The video also makes a point Health Canada agrees with: tap samples taken at random can miss the times when fibre levels jump. 1,8
Our reading so far: we have found no good evidence that a glass of tap water or a shower here is dangerous. We are still checking the reports and studies raised locally, and we'll update this section as we do. In the meantime, it is fair to ask the Town for a replacement schedule, careful flushing after work on mains, testing at hydrants and after repairs, and published results.
What about PFAS, the "forever chemicals"? The Town's annual water reports for 2023 to 2025 list no tests for PFAS. 10,11 Health Canada's benchmark is 30 nanograms per litre for 25 PFAS added together. It is an objective, not a binding limit. 15 HealthLinkBC tells residents to ask their water supplier whether PFAS is part of its regular monitoring, and says many suppliers may not have that information yet. 16 At Canadian airports, the main known source of PFAS is firefighting foam, especially where crews trained with it or fought fires. 17 We found no Town record of firefighting foam being used or stored at Qualicum Beach Airport. The Berwick wells are about 3 km from the airport, and provincial maps show the same aquifer under both. It is a confined aquifer, with a layer of tighter soil above it, and the Province rates it moderately vulnerable to pollution from the surface. 18 None of this means there is a problem. We found no sign that anyone has checked. It is fair to ask the Town to test its wells for PFAS and publish the results.
Sources for this section
- Health Canada: Draft guidance on asbestos in drinking water, January 2026 (opens in a new tab)
- World Health Organization: Asbestos in drinking-water, background document, 2021 (opens in a new tab)
- US EPA: National Primary Drinking Water Regulations (opens in a new tab) asbestos row: limit and health basis
- Australian Drinking Water Guidelines: Asbestos (opens in a new tab)
- Go et al.: Review of studies on health effects from swallowing asbestos in drinking water, Critical Reviews in Toxicology, 2024 (opens in a new tab)
- Kjærheim et al.: Asbestos in drinking water and cancer among Norwegian lighthouse keepers, 2005 (opens in a new tab)
- WorkSafeBC: Asbestos-containing pipes in municipal underground works projects (opens in a new tab)
- Mager et al.: Asbestos fibres in Christchurch, New Zealand's drinking water, 2022 (opens in a new tab) hydrant and tap samples
- Regular Council agenda, Oct 22, 2025 (opens in a new tab) water rates report, p. 139
- Town of Qualicum Beach: Annual Water Report 2025 (opens in a new tab) River well tests, p. 16
- Town of Qualicum Beach: Annual Water Reports (all years) (opens in a new tab) 2023 and 2024 well tests
- Staff memo: Asbestos-Cement Pipe Concerns, May 2023 (opens in a new tab)
- Video: Regular Council meeting, Sep 9, 2026, from 3:08:00 (opens in a new tab) Town of Qualicum Beach
- Video: Analyzing Qualicum Beach Asbestos pipes, Sep 29, 2026 (opens in a new tab) a resident's commentary (advocacy)
- Health Canada: Objective for Canadian drinking water quality, PFAS, August 2024 (opens in a new tab)
- HealthLinkBC File 49i: PFAS in drinking water, December 2024 (opens in a new tab)
- Milley et al.: Estimating the number of airports potentially contaminated with PFAS from firefighting foam: a Canadian example, Journal of Environmental Management, 2018 (opens in a new tab)
- Province of BC, GWELLS: Aquifer 217 (Qualicum) (opens in a new tab) confined sand and gravel; vulnerability moderate
What happened
- May 2023After a CTV W5 report on asbestos-cement pipes, the Town tests its water at four sites. Seven of eight samples find no asbestos fibres and one finds a single fibre. Staff conclude there is no issue.
- October 22, 2025Staff tell Council that tests on samples of the Town's asbestos-cement pipe show it will need replacing within 10 to 20 years, at a cost of about $48 million.
- November 12, 2025Staff write that water reserve contributions are too low and some renewals have been deferred.
- December 17, 2025Council gives early approval to replace the Seacrest Place asbestos-cement water main in 2026, at $900,000 (unanimous).
- January 2026Health Canada releases draft guidance on asbestos in drinking water for public comment. It proposes no limit, and says asbestos-cement pipe should be replaced as it wears out.
- April 1, 2026The 2026–2030 Financial Plan plans the Eaglecrest Drive water main ($1,113,000) for 2028, paid from Eaglecrest land sales.
- June 24, 2026Staff recommend paying for the Eaglecrest Drive water main and storm main from asset management reserves instead of Eaglecrest land sales. Council adopts this change on July 15.
- June 24, 2026Council awards the Seacrest Place water main to In The Dirt Contracting for $338,403 before GST (unanimous). With contingency and other costs the project needs $431,403, against a $900,000 budget. It removes the last asbestos-cement main on the street.
- June 29, 2026Council approves applying for a federal grant for the Eaglecrest Drive water main and storm main, total $2,863,000 (unanimous).
- September 9, 2026Staff report that construction on Seacrest Place (310 m of pipe) is expected to start in the third quarter of 2026. Staff ask Council to move $13,000 to finish the design for Berwick Road and Crescent Road East, for construction planned in 2027. At the same meeting a councillor asked about replacing asbestos-cement pipe sooner. Staff said there is no risk to the water and offered a memo on the water system in early 2027.
- October 1, 2026Work starts on Seacrest Place, planned to run to November 12.
Why it matters
- Water work is paid from the Town's separate water fund, which comes from water user fees and a yearly water parcel tax. None of the Eaglecrest purchase money came from the water fund.
- The 2026–2030 Financial Plan says replacement costs in 2026 are higher than what is added to the water reserve that year.
- The plan aims to replace over $1 million of asbestos-cement water main every year for 10 years.
- A Water Master Plan, including an assessment of the asbestos-cement pipes, is expected to go to Council in early 2027.
- Sewer pipe is usually buried deeper than water pipe, so it may cost more per metre than the Town's water rates. The Town says its sewer system is "in relatively good condition." A condition assessment that includes the asbestos-cement sewer mains is planned.
- No law we found makes the Town dig up old pipe that is left alone. WorkSafeBC says pipe outside a dig can stay in the ground, as long as it is on the Town's asbestos list. But if a dig uncovers old pipe that is breaking down, that pipe must be taken out or sealed. Our high estimate counts removal of all abandoned pipe anyway.
- The Town's mapping shows 558 m of asbestos-cement water main left in the ground along Country Club Drive since 1993. That is the longest abandoned stretch on any street in town. The Town is now selling land beside it, part of the former Eaglecrest golf course, for development. WorkSafeBC says old, unused pipe that is uncovered during a dig and is breaking down must be removed or properly sealed. Burying it again does not count. The records we found don't say how this pipe will be handled when the land is developed.
- By our count of the Town's mapping, about a third of the town's abandoned asbestos-cement water pipe is in the Eaglecrest area: about 0.7 km, including Country Club Drive. Eaglecrest also has about 1.9 km still in service.
- Inflation: BC's highway construction cost index rose 5.5%, 7.0% and 4.2% in 2021 to 2023, and forecasts about 2.4% a year to 2030. Statistics Canada's non-residential building costs rose 4.1% in 2025. Town staff say infrastructure inflation has run "substantially higher than CPI." We used 4% a year for our high estimate.
- The Town's mapping lists nearly every pipe in "Excellent" condition, including old asbestos-cement pipe. Those condition fields don't appear to reflect real inspections.
- Across Canada, local governments reported almost 13,700 km of asbestos-cement water pipe in the 2022 Statistics Canada survey. BC reported the most, 4,261 km. Only about two in three local governments answered the question.
- In the United States, the Environmental Protection Agency has set a limit for asbestos in drinking water since 1992: 7 million fibres per litre. It names wearing-out asbestos-cement water mains as a source. Canada has no limit.
- Studies from a National Research Council centre in Regina (2010–2011) warned that worn asbestos-cement pipe can shed fibres into drinking water and "could pose a hazard of malignant tumours." One of the authors now calls the risk minor.
- WorkSafeBC says old asbestos-cement pipe that is breaking down and is uncovered during a dig must be removed or properly sealed. Reburying it does not count. Pipe beyond the dig can stay in the ground, but the owner and employer must keep a list of it.
- WorkSafeBC's asbestos abatement licence, required since 2024, covers work on buildings. WorkSafeBC says no licence is needed to remove asbestos-cement pipe. Crews still need an exposure control plan and safe work procedures for it.
- Health Canada says there are no accredited labs in Canada that test drinking water for asbestos. Samples go to labs in the United States.
- In August 2026, the provincial Finance Committee's Budget 2027 report said members discussed funding to renew aging water systems, including to address safety concerns about asbestos-cement pipes. The report also sums up a June 2026 presentation that asked the Province to map abandoned asbestos-cement pipe and to fund a 10-year plan to remove it.
- Staff also wrote that the Town's Asset Replacement Reserve is underfunded for buildings, drainage, fleet and roads.
Sources
- Committee of the Whole agenda and scoping sheets, Nov 12, 2025 (opens in a new tab)
- Regular Council agenda and staff reports, Oct 22, 2025 (opens in a new tab) water rates report: 28.5 km, $48 million and pipe testing, p. 139; sewer mains, p. 147
- Regular Council agenda and staff reports, Jun 18, 2025 (opens in a new tab) Hemlock Street and Illiqua Road tender, pp. 270–271
- Staff memo: Asbestos-Cement Pipe Concerns, May 2023 (opens in a new tab) water test results; also p. 124 of the May 24, 2023 Council agenda
- Special Council minutes, Dec 17, 2025 (opens in a new tab) Res. 25-366, p. 9
- 2026–2030 Financial Plan (adopted Apr 1, 2026) (opens in a new tab) water fund p. 41; water utility pp. 117–122; capital budget p. 122
- Regular Council agenda, Jun 24, 2026 (opens in a new tab) staff report, pp. 242, 244; Seacrest Place tender, pp. 476–477
- Financial Plan Amendment Bylaw No. 921.01 (adopted Jul 15, 2026) (opens in a new tab)
- Special Council minutes, Jun 29, 2026 (opens in a new tab) Res. 26-162, p. 1
- Regular Council agenda and staff reports, Sep 9, 2026 (opens in a new tab) capital update, pp. 140–141
- Special Council agenda and deferral lists, Jul 23, 2025 (opens in a new tab) Eaglecrest funding sources, p. 6
- Prevent Cancer Now: Where are Canada's asbestos cement drinking water pipes? (opens in a new tab) Statistics Canada 2022 survey data, by province and local government
- Health Canada: Draft guidance on asbestos in drinking water, January 2026 (opens in a new tab) section B.6.2.3 on asbestos-cement pipe and monitoring
- WorkSafeBC: Asbestos-containing pipes in municipal underground works projects (opens in a new tab)
- BC Ministry of Transportation: Highway Construction Cost Indexes, Apr 2023 (opens in a new tab)
- Statistics Canada: Building construction price indexes, fourth quarter 2025 (opens in a new tab)
- BC Finance Committee: Report on the Budget 2027 Consultation, Aug 2026 (opens in a new tab) pp. 52, 58
- Town of Qualicum Beach: Public Mapping & GIS (utility map) (opens in a new tab) water pipe material, status and dates; the Town says it will replace this map by the end of November 2026
- Town of Qualicum Beach: Eaglecrest Land Sales (opens in a new tab)
- US EPA: National Primary Drinking Water Regulations (opens in a new tab) asbestos limit
- Prevent Cancer Now: Canada's asbestos cement water pipe research, a brief history (opens in a new tab) National Research Council studies, 2003–2012
- Watershed Sentinel: Asbestos: Deadly to Breathe But OK to Drink? (opens in a new tab) further reading; mentions Qualicum Beach
- World Health Organization: Asbestos in drinking-water, background document, 2021 (opens in a new tab)
- Go et al.: Review of studies on health effects from swallowing asbestos in drinking water, Critical Reviews in Toxicology, 2024 (opens in a new tab) includes Health Canada authors
- Kjærheim et al.: Asbestos in drinking water and cancer among Norwegian lighthouse keepers, Cancer Causes & Control, 2005 (opens in a new tab)
- Mager et al.: Asbestos fibres in Christchurch, New Zealand's drinking water, Water Supply, 2022 (opens in a new tab) hydrant and tap samples
- Town of Qualicum Beach: Annual Water Report 2025 (opens in a new tab) well water tests, pp. 15–16
- Regular Council minutes, Jun 24, 2026 (opens in a new tab) Seacrest Place contract, Res. 26-143, p. 3
- Video: Regular Council meeting, Sep 9, 2026 (asbestos-cement pipe discussion from 3:08:00) (opens in a new tab) Town of Qualicum Beach
- Video: Analyzing Qualicum Beach Asbestos pipes, Sep 29, 2026 (opens in a new tab) a resident's commentary (advocacy)
- WorkSafeBC: Learn about asbestos abatement licences (opens in a new tab)
- Health Canada: Objective for Canadian drinking water quality, PFAS, August 2024 (opens in a new tab)
- HealthLinkBC File 49i: PFAS in drinking water, December 2024 (opens in a new tab)
- Milley et al.: Estimating the number of airports potentially contaminated with PFAS from firefighting foam: a Canadian example, Journal of Environmental Management, 2018 (opens in a new tab)
- Province of BC, GWELLS: Aquifer 217 (Qualicum) (opens in a new tab) confined sand and gravel; vulnerability moderate
Last checked October 13, 2026. Report a mistake.